Should you shame your kids online?

Ashleigh Mutimer
Friday, February 8, 2013
Image posted on website Reddit by parent
Image posted on website Reddit by parent

What do you do when your child breaks the rules? Shout at them? Take away their favourite toy? Post a humiliating photo of them on Facebook, which quickly goes viral exposing their wrongdoing to millions and staying online to haunt them for the rest of their lives?

It seems extreme, but an increasing number of parents are choosing the last option, publicly shaming their kids on social media networks when they misbehave.

American father Tommy Jordan became an internet sensation after a video of him shooting his daughter's laptop — with a gun — went viral.

Jordan's daughter had written petulant comments about her parents on Facebook, prompting Jordan to retaliate with his own brand of tough love.

The video prompted outrage, with some critics complaining to the police but the detectives, Jordan said, were entirely on his side. 'The police, by the way, said "Kudos, Sir" and most of them made their kids watch it,' he said. "I actually had a 'thank you' from an entire detectives squad … another police officer is using it in a positive manner in his presentation for the school system.

'How's about those apples? Didn't expect THAT when you called the cops did you?'

Another father (unnamed) took to website Reddit after his three-year-old daughter had a potty training incident in the shower.

In a rather questionable parenting move, he uploaded a photo of his daughter (pictured) with a sign around her neck reading: 'I pooped in the shower and daddy (sic) had to clean it up. I hereby sign this as permission to use in my yearbook senior year.'

The photo sparked a major backlash on the site, with the majority of users labelling the father's actions 'sick' and 'exploitative'.

Reddit user ilikepix wrote: 'You don't make a child tough and resilient by having her parents, who are meant to be the two people in the world she can trust absolutely, set out to embarrass her in the most public of settings.'

The father jokingly replied that his daughter can sue him for 'defecation' not defamation.

In the latest example of tough love, another father has taken to Reddit after his teenage daughter stayed out past her curfew.

He posted a photo of his daughter wearing a t-shirt emblazoned with a photo of his scowling face and captioned 'Try Me', which he made her wear to school every day for a week.

Reddit users called his actions 'illogical' and suggested that posts like his are 'more about the parent getting attention than a well thought through attempt to alter a child's behaviour'.

Whether you believe these measures are tame, controversial or just plain abusive, experts say that shaming children into obedience is counterproductive and greatly increases their chance of developing low self-esteem.

Parenting and resilience specialist Maggie Dent says this new trend in parental discipline makes her feel 'physically sick' as she knows the kind of damage it can do.

'Any one of us has a moment of shame that we can recall from childhood,' she says.

We tend to hold onto that moment as adults and it can become 'life crippling'.

Which begs the question — would you want your moment to be immortalised on the internet, readily accessible to anyone via a search engine?

Recipe Search

Tip: Try "lamb & potato" or "Low GI"
advertisement
    Features
    Pictures
    Video
    Potato and leek soup2 medium potatoes (400g), chopped coarsely 2 medium carrots (240g), chopped coarsely 1 large brown onion (200g), chopped coarsely 1 medium tomato (150g), chopped coarsely 1 stalk celery (150g), trimmed, chopped coarsely 1.5 litres (6 cups) water 1 tablespoon olive oil 50g butter 4 medium potatoes (800g), chopped coarsely, extra 1 large leek (500g), sliced thickly 300ml cream 2 tablespoons finely chopped fresh chives 1 tablespoon finely chopped fresh basil 1 tablespoon finely chopped fresh dill Hearty bacon, lentil and vegetable soup1 tablespoon olive oil 1 medium (150g) brown onion, chopped finely 4 (280g) bacon rashers, chopped finely 2 sticks (300g) celery, trimmed, chopped coarsely 2 medium (240g) carrots, chopped coarsely 2 cloves garlic, crushed 1 cup (200g) red lentils 1 litre (4 cups) salt-reduced chicken stock 1/4 cup finely chopped fresh chives Chicken and sweet corn soup3 cups (750ml) salt-reduced chicken stock 1 cup (250ml) water 2 tablespoons Chinese cooking wine or sherry 3cm piece (15g) fresh ginger, grated 1 clove garlic, sliced thinly 2 teaspoons salt-reduced soy sauce 2 (400g) chicken breast fillets 1 egg 420g can creamed corn 310g can corn kernels, rinsed, drained 3 green onions (green shallots), sliced thinly Pea and ham soup1 medium (150g) brown onion, chopped coarsely 2 trimmed (200g) celery stalks, chopped coarsely 2 bay leaves 1.5kg ham hocks 2.5 litres (10 cups) water 1 teaspoon cracked black pepper 2 cups (375g) split green peas Chunky beef and vegetable soup2 tablespoons olive oil 600g gravy beef, trimmed, cut into 2cm pieces 1 medium brown onion (150g), chopped coarsely 1 clove garlic, crushed 1.5 litres (6 cups) water 1 cup (250ml) beef stock 400g can diced tomatoes 2 trimmed celery stalks (200g), cut into 1cm pieces 1 medium carrot (120g), cut into 1cm pieces 2 small potatoes (240g), cut into 1cm pieces 310g can corn kernels, rinsed, drained ½ cup (60g) frozen peas

    How mining is making the world a worse...

    How mining is making the world a worse place for womenWhile mining has undoubtedly been kind to at least one woman, Gina Rinehart,...More >

    Megan Gale shines on Cannes red carpet

    Megan Gale shines on Cannes red carpetShe's walked kilometres of red carpet in her time, but Megan Gale says nothing...More >
    Horoscopes by Jessica AdamsHoroscopes by Jessica Adams The ultimate Mother's Day gift guideThe ultimate Mother's Day gift guide

    Weekly newsletter

    Recipes in your inboxWe send you the latest recipes from the Weekly plus all the week's best bits to your inbox.
    Sign up now >
    ww |

    topics

    Handy hints(740)/ Expert advice(530)/ Books(451)/ natural health(438)/ Royals(388)/ diet(369)/ Food(360)/ Recipes(350)/ Royal Family(320)/ Health(284)/ Celebrities(253)

    Also on Ninemsn