I'm just a girl who can say 'no'!

Julie Hamilton
Wednesday, October 7, 2009
Getty Images
Getty Images
We've all been there: standing in the supermarket and some child (yes, it's been mine many times) starts the whine. It goes like this: "I want that lolly/toy/juice/packet of nuclear-strength sugared treats." Repeat a hundred times in escalating hysteria and an ear-piercing pitch.


Taking a stand
In my in-depth research on this, I can report that 97 times out of a hundred, the parent caves in and buys the child the object of their momentary obsession. All the while, I stand there watching the parent, inwardly wishing them to stand their ground.

I've even been known to go up and congratulate parents who have withstood the deluge of begging that a child has launched at them in a public place. Why? Because I'm on a private campaign to bring back the word "no".

I can't get no satisfaction
I once read an article that said that by the time a child is two they hear the word "no" about a hundred times a day. The author, rightly, pointed out that this is a huge amount of negativity and suggested other ways of diverting junior from whatever was consuming them at the time.

Distraction, bribery, reasoning, offering a better alternative were all offered as suitable ways of breaking the news that they couldn't do as they pleased. I agree with all of the above. If someone said "no" to me a hundred times a day, I'd probably want to go home and go to bed. But here's the thing: fundamentally, kids have to learn how to handle not being able to do whatever they want, whenever they want.

Tough love
They have to understand that they don't actually know everything and that a giant ice-cream, unlimited TV, fast-food takeaway and staying up extremely late every evening, is not Nirvana even if it looks that way.

Part of the learning curve is understanding that old people — us — do sometimes know more about stuff than just paying the bills and handing over cash. Children need to learn that boundaries are important, as is learning to live with disappointment. They also need to learn that these challenges build character and resilience and creativity, which are the tools for life that our kids really need.

No means, no!
It's not fashionable. We live in an instant-gratification culture. It's difficult to teach these things when the whole planet is going down the tubes because us grown-ups have wanted everything, "right now", for so long. We've got a lot of reality checks coming our way, too. And it's not popular.

You have to be able to withstand a lot of displeasure when you say "no" to an articulate pre-teen. But actually being able to take it on the chin is part of what being a parent is about.

The best things in life are …
Explaining to a child that they may have to go without, because money is a bit tight right now or because they don't need it, might bring up their resentment — especially if all their friends have one. But it also teaches them that life can be uneven and that the things that make a family happy, actually don't cost the earth.

Read more from Julie at her website Omigoddess

Your say: How do you get the 'no' message through to your child? Do you often give in? Share with us below...

User comments
I have a teenage daughter that lived with me for 14 years, I quiet often said no, To comments like I want phone credit, Why carnt I hang around the shops till 10pm, I want I want etc. Not having the money to buy these things, also not wanting to spoil my kids rotten. What did i get in the end, a mouth fun of swearing and she moved to her dads so she can get what she wants. So saying no isnt always the best. I hardly hear from her now unless she wants something, the answer is still no. hopefully one day she will realise.
I HATE when my daughter starts screaming in a public place but I refuse to give in because she is very bright and will soon work out that I cave if there are people about. She threw the BIGGEST tantrum ever in Myer in the city and I was mortified. I ended up finding a deserted corner and putting her on the *** spot then and there until she calmed down - I was talking to her to try to help her calm down and when people walked past I looked at them very apologetically and simply said "We're learning we can't get our own way by having a tantrum". For the most part, she is fabulous when we go places but on the odd day she isn't .... well I just remind myself that one of us is going to win and better be me if I don't want to have this problem again!
I consider myself reasonably good at standing my ground. If my 2 year old 'chucks a hissy' when he doesn't get what he wants and throws himself down on the ground, I just walk away into another room or outside until he calms down, which usually only take a few minutes. By the time he has finished his hissy, we are onto playing or reading a book etc. The difficulty I have is that my in-laws aren't as good when is comes to junk food and treats and take it personally when a toddler or baby cries. I know part of the fun of being a grandparent is being able to give your grandchildren treats that their parents don't otherwise give, but if I give them an 'inch they take a mile'. Often telling me they gave my son cake instead of the second banana he actually asked for, because he had already had one banana and they thought he should have something else. Therefore, when I say 'no' to the same thing, he has a tanty as he doesn't understand why he can't have it this time.
Growing up, my parents were forever telling me 'no'. The money situation was tight and there was rarely any treats, and rarely special things, except at Christmas. My mum says that I was the only child who threw a tantrum - and I only did it once! My parents were very firm believers in buying things we needed, not always the things we wanted. And guess what? None of the four of us grew into psychopaths or murderers or anything like that. Two of us have graduated Year 12 with scores of higher than 80 and the other two are both smart, well-rounded people. DON'T BE AFRAID TO SAY NO!
i'm sitting here reading all your comments and feeling a little better, the problem i have is that i always feel like i'm the fun police and my daughters dad gets to be the good guy. being a single mum is hard and with not much commuication from her father my daughter knows she can play us off against one another. trying to have rules at home is hard when you know that they are getting broken at her fathers house and i get 'i'm allowed at daddy's house' thrown back at me. i'm trying the best i can and most of the time she is a good girl but am worried as she gets older this is going to get harder. not much fun being the bad guy all the time but hopefully she will see one day i'm doing it for her best intrest!
I can now discuss with amusement a huge "tanty" child No 3 was having in the supermarket aisle because I was not giving in to her - she was so spectacular that an elderly woman came up and asked me if I needed any help! I simply told the kind lady I was ignoring my child as she was being unreasonable. ( hmmm does there appear to be a common FEMALE thread here? - daughters can be testing...!)
When my children had to come shopping with me (before they went to school) before we left the house i would say " we are going to the shops and I am only going to buy what is on the list. I will not be buying lollies, chips, toys or anything like that" I had to stick to my rule too but they got used to no frills shopping trips and knew there was no point in asking and I didn't even have to say no!
I've told my kids that they have every right to ask for something they want. But if the answer is no, I mean it. I've also told them that to continue to ask after being given an answer will result in a louder version of No. It will not result in capitulation. They also know if they throw a tantrum in public, I will stop what I'm doing and go into my favourite song and dance routine. If they act embarassingly, so will I. I have had to do this on two occassions and it's a brilliant way to get them to stop in their tracks (and one occasion applause from shoppers...). My friends call me a "mean mum" because I don't give into my children - but I've met their kids and quite frankly - I know whose kids will have a better time adjusting to the adult world - mine. When work experience kids come into work - you can tell the kids whose parents taught them right and who caved every time. PS. I know some adults who should learn you can't get what you want the exact second you want it too!.
after you say no, if the child continues to "carry on", simply give them a good smacking. kids are so bloody spoiled by you idiots pandering to their every whim. you child is NOT special. statistically speaking, it is more than likely, very, very avaerage. or even ordinary. all of us (over 32) who grew up with a good belting when it was deserved know about boundaries and life. that's why we have houses and jobs and our own lives. kids who don't get smacked live with their parents until they're 30, don't lift a finger and are the same kids who went on "gap years" or had their parents pay for their schoolies hotel room. failure to acknowledge this is the only solution means you are a bad, ineffective, sefish failure of a parent.
I often hear experts say that you should pick the fights that you want to have with your preschoolers, however I disagree. If your kids are not used to hearing you say no because you have chosen in the past not to have that particular fight they don't know how to behave. Say No to them at home - give them plenty of practice as to how they should behave when they hear the word No - then when they hear it in the supermarket they will be more likely to behave well. The word does not lose its effect if you always mean it, no matter how many times you say it each day.

Recipe Search

Tip: Try "lamb & potato" or "Low GI"
advertisement
Features
Pictures
Video
Magda Szubanski comes out as a lesbianComedian and actress Magda Szubanski will today announce she is gay, as she joins the push to legalise same-sex marriage in Australia. Baking soda, bicarb soda, baking powder. what is the difference?Question: What is the difference between baking powder, baking soda and bicarbonate of soda? What are their different applications? Butter chicken1 cup (150g) unsalted raw cashews 2 teaspoons garam masala 2 teaspoons ground coriander ½ teaspoon chilli powder 3 cloves garlic, chopped coarsely 4cm piece fresh ginger (20g), grated 2 tablespoons white vinegar 1/3 cup (90g) tomato paste ½ cup (140g) yogurt 1kg chicken thigh fillets, halved 80g butter 1 large brown onion (200g), chopped finely 1 cinnamon stick 4 cardamom pods, bruised 1 teaspoon hot paprika 400g can tomato puree ¾ cup (180ml) chicken stock ¾ cup (180ml) cream Note: This recipe is not suitable to make in a slow cooker or pressure cooker. Use unsalted cashews in the roasted curry mixture or the taste of the finished butter chicken may not be as mellow as it could be. Angelina Jolie: How I avoided a horrible lifeAngelina Jolie has revealed how she escaped the "shallow" life many Hollywood stars live in a candid new video. How to cook a soft-boiled eggThere is a great debate and many points of view on how to boil the perfect egg. However, there are a few points that all the experts agree on.

Glam and garish Grammys fashion

Glam and garish Grammys fashionThe red carpet fashion at this year's Grammy Awards was split into two...More >

Miranda Kerr-ves: Australia's sexiest...

Miranda Kerr-ves: Australia's sexiest supermodelThirty years after Elle Macpherson was crowned 'The Body', Australia has a new...More >
The very best retro recipesThe very best retro recipes Marvellous mocktailsMarvellous mocktails

Recipes in your inbox

Recipes in your inboxWe send you the latest recipes from the weekly straight to your inbox.
Sign up now >
ww |

topics

Handy hints(740)/ Expert advice(530)/ natural health(434)/ Books(384)/ diet(343)/ Health(237)/ Recipes(234)/ Gardening(217)/ Food(206)/ Craft(164)/ Diet and nutrition(151)

Also on Ninemsn