I'm just a girl who can say 'no'!

Julie Hamilton
Wednesday, October 7, 2009
Getty Images
Getty Images
We've all been there: standing in the supermarket and some child (yes, it's been mine many times) starts the whine. It goes like this: "I want that lolly/toy/juice/packet of nuclear-strength sugared treats." Repeat a hundred times in escalating hysteria and an ear-piercing pitch.


Taking a stand
In my in-depth research on this, I can report that 97 times out of a hundred, the parent caves in and buys the child the object of their momentary obsession. All the while, I stand there watching the parent, inwardly wishing them to stand their ground.

I've even been known to go up and congratulate parents who have withstood the deluge of begging that a child has launched at them in a public place. Why? Because I'm on a private campaign to bring back the word "no".

I can't get no satisfaction
I once read an article that said that by the time a child is two they hear the word "no" about a hundred times a day. The author, rightly, pointed out that this is a huge amount of negativity and suggested other ways of diverting junior from whatever was consuming them at the time.

Distraction, bribery, reasoning, offering a better alternative were all offered as suitable ways of breaking the news that they couldn't do as they pleased. I agree with all of the above. If someone said "no" to me a hundred times a day, I'd probably want to go home and go to bed. But here's the thing: fundamentally, kids have to learn how to handle not being able to do whatever they want, whenever they want.

Tough love
They have to understand that they don't actually know everything and that a giant ice-cream, unlimited TV, fast-food takeaway and staying up extremely late every evening, is not Nirvana even if it looks that way.

Part of the learning curve is understanding that old people — us — do sometimes know more about stuff than just paying the bills and handing over cash. Children need to learn that boundaries are important, as is learning to live with disappointment. They also need to learn that these challenges build character and resilience and creativity, which are the tools for life that our kids really need.

No means, no!
It's not fashionable. We live in an instant-gratification culture. It's difficult to teach these things when the whole planet is going down the tubes because us grown-ups have wanted everything, "right now", for so long. We've got a lot of reality checks coming our way, too. And it's not popular.

You have to be able to withstand a lot of displeasure when you say "no" to an articulate pre-teen. But actually being able to take it on the chin is part of what being a parent is about.

The best things in life are …
Explaining to a child that they may have to go without, because money is a bit tight right now or because they don't need it, might bring up their resentment — especially if all their friends have one. But it also teaches them that life can be uneven and that the things that make a family happy, actually don't cost the earth.

Read more from Julie at her website Omigoddess

Your say: How do you get the 'no' message through to your child? Do you often give in? Share with us below...

SHARE:
MESSENGER
FACEBOOK
MORE
Blog on Spaces
Add to delicious
Add to Digg
Share on MySpace
?
Share, bookmark, and save your favourite ninemsn articles and features.  Learn more.
User comments
Saying no is like exercising, without hard effort the payoff is unwanted excess. Hearing no teaches the child he or she is not the ruler of their small world with you as the obedient servant. Better they learn the lesson sooner than later when both of you are unwilling to negotiate on anything since one is expecting it all to be supplied while the other is tired of feeling used.
When I used to go to the shops and my toddler would have a tantrum I used to discipline her with other people in mind which usually meant giving in to spare everyone of the tantrum. NOW I don't care that other people are staring if I say NO then that is it. I am sorry you have to hear my child screaming but if I give in now I will have to continue to give in.
Bravo! I am so happy to see that there are mothers out their who don't give in to the demands of their children. They will be better equiped to deal with denial and failure and won't need mummy to fight all thier battles even when they are supposedly grown adults. Childern of all ages need to learn boundaries and that there are consequences for misbehaviour and that whinging or proceeding with the behaviour that they were told NOT TO DO actually results in a consequence that will be carried out despite their displeasure. People with no boundaries enforced consistently are truely surprised when they are not allowed to do something or get something as they don't experience denial.
Is it wrong of me to laugh (on the inside of course) when my 16 month old daughter throws a tantrum because I have said no?? I think ultimatly all infants, children, teens need to learn that they can't have everything. I can't wait for the terrible two's!
Say... NO..., mean it, follow up with a reason- from the start. It can help in the child's teens by then they.. "NO".. if you really mean it or not when it comes to testing the boundries
When out and my daughters ask for things - particularly lollies and toys - I say 'no'. If they ask, they generally do not get the thing they desire. I always say, "If you ask it is no, you will be offered if I want to get it for you!"
I have taught my Rag Doll pussycat, aged 5, the meaning of NO and he accepts it! I tell him No when he is doing something he should not, and then as soon as he stops, tell him "Good Boooy!" He loves that, and now No is simply sufficient, and he waits to be praised. He loves the good boy afterwards and the attention. And children can be taught the same way, That Mummy is pleased when they do as asked, and will receive a cuddle. Praise goes a long way.
I had a mantra I repeated often to my daughter when she was little "the more you whinge, the less you get". She could come & ask once politely & I would respond "let me think about it". If she went & behaved well she knew I would reward that behaviour (& helpfulness). She may not get exactly what she requested, but her good behaviour was always rewarded in some way, often praise & appreciation was enough. However, she knew from early experience that if she tried to throw a tantrum or whined it would be a cold day in hell before she'd get what she wanted. At 14 she wagged school on her birthday & put her life at risk climbing in a high window in our house to get changed out of her uniform. The school rang me at work & when I caught up with her & she lied about where she was. I cancelled her birthday dinner. No cake, nothing. It was one of the hardest & most depressing things I ever had to do parenting, but she had betrayed my trust & endangered herself, I couldn't treat it lightly.
Bravo!
Hi - easier said than done - especially after having come through the teen years. BUT it can be done! With smaller children offer them two choices - for example at dressing time with a small girl or boy - hold up two outfits that you are happy with and say "do you want to wear this one or this one?" No tantrums, they think they're getting a choice and then if they um and ah - at least the whole room and wardrobe isn't being torn apart. I'm so sick of hearing wishy washy mothers giving in to their kids - get some backbone! For older kids a bit of cunning is required and teenagers - they're a breed apart - keep the lines of communication open and be certain in your mind that "no, not all of their friends are getting $50 per week pocket money" and no, "they're all not allowed to stay out till 3am" and "no, you can't have a drink" You are entitled to a life as well, your teenager doesn't think you have one now or you ever did by the way, but as you get older the worry gets less!

Write a comment
Email: *
Your email will not be shared with any third parties or published with your comment.
Nickname: *
Location: *

Subject:
*
Comment:
*
Maximum characters 1000

Comment guidelines
Avoid using:
  • Personal attacks
  • Irrelevant comments
  • HTML tags
  • Personal information
  • Offensive language
  • Text in ALL CAPITAL LETTERS
See full comment guidelines
Comment guidelines X
Thank you for sharing your opinions with other users of NineMSN. People will find your comments more helpful if you include relevant information and avoid some common pitfalls.
Please note: All reviews and comments submitted are subject to moderation, NineMSN reserves the right to alter and / or remove any content that does not comply with usage guidelines.
What to include in your comment:
  • A title that briefly summarizes the opinion expressed in the comment.
  • Additional comments adding more detail.
  • Comparisons to other similar products, if this is relevant.
  • To create a new paragraph, press the Enter key twice.
What not to include:
  • Information that will quickly go out of date.
  • Comments on other comments or commenters.
  • Language that other users may find offensive.
  • comments of one sentence or less. Provide information to support your opinion.
  • Personal information like your email address or telephone number.
  • HTML coding. Tags like <b> or <i> will not be recognized.

Recipe Search

Tip: Try "lamb & potato" or "Low GI"
advertisement
Features
Pictures
Video
Say good riddance to fat: Manage the IN vs OUTMagazines feature new fad diets every week. Low fat, no carbs, South Beach Diet, cabbage soup diet, high fat, Atkins … are you confused? Fed up with all the hype and the fact you are still trying to lose weight? Read on. Robin Hood for divorced womenYou hear the same old story trumped out a lot, the woman who was happily married to a well off man in a wealthy suburb, has three young children then all of a sudden, he moves out. The no-diet weight loss strategy that actually worksThe no-diet weight loss strategy that actually works. Strength training for women; the secret to an amazing body at any ageStrength training does not make you 'big'. To get big muscles you need to train a lot, very hard and with very heavy weights and you also need testosterone. This is hard enough for men and extremely difficult for women... Overcoming the weight loss plateauHere’s something you won’t read about all that often: weight loss is not a linear process. In other words, you’re unlikely to lose a predictable 1 or 2 kilograms per week until you get down to where you want to be.

Barbecued soy and ginger lamb with...

Barbecued soy and ginger lamb with coriander potatoesThe barbecue is the perfect way to cook a butterflied leg of lamb. Have your...More >

Char-grilled t-bones with potato pancakes

Char-grilled t-bones with potato pancakesLet the crisp potato pancakes soak up some of the zesty chilli and ginger...More >

Recipes in your inbox

Recipes in your inboxWe send you the latest recipes from the weekly straight to your inbox.
Sign up now >
ww |

topics

Handy hints(740)/ Expert advice(533)/ natural health(427)/ diet(265)/ Gardening(190)/ Books(179)/ Craft(165)/ Cleaning tips(149)/ Kids(121)/ Health(101)/ Beauty(95)