Three of these women are fat, doctor says

Monday, October 29, 2012
'Three of these women are fat', doctor says
A recent Marks and Spencer shapewear advertisement.

Thousands of Australian women would love to look half as good as these lovely lingerie models, but a British doctor thinks two of them are overweight, while one is obese.

The five models above feature in a shapewear campaign for UK department store Marks and Spencer. Like many ordinary women, they range in size from eight to 16, but Dr Ellie Cannon thinks they set an unhealthy example no one should aspire to.

Related: Am I really overweight?

"Fat, truth be told, is neither a feminist nor a cosmetic issue," she wrote in a piece published in the Daily Mail. "It is, quite simply, a health issue. And we shouldn't allow ourselves to be steered into losing sight of that fact.

"The fact is it is absolutely outrageous that, in an effort to illustrate the diversity of women, obesity has taken its place alongside ageing and differing skin colours.

"Yes, these adverts have captured the notion of individuality beautifully, by using women in their 50s. But including overweight — and therefore unhealthy — women in the mix is downright misguided, at best. "

Dr Cannon says she treats women struggling with obesity-related health issues in her GP practice every day, and is appalled that it is now acceptable to be overweight.

While she is glad many companies have stopped hiring skeletal models, she says the current trend of celebrating obese ones is just as dangerous.

"I am really concerned by this trend of supposedly empowering women by what has become known as the 'body acceptance movement' which embraces the notion that fat is fine," she wrote.

"While fat may be fine cosmetically, it is not fine for your health. Body shape has been hijacked solely as a fashion issue and as ammunition in the war of cool versus uncool.

Related: Why obesity is not your fault

"We know from studies of anorexics that when they idolise and obsess over images of these very thin women, it exacerbates their illness and perpetuates their self-loathing and body dysmorphia.

"Isn't it just as irresponsible to promote the notion that being overweight is perfectly normal?"

Your say: Do you think overweight models are just as dangerous as underweight ones?

Recipe Search

Tip: Try "lamb & potato" or "Low GI"
advertisement
    Features
    Pictures
    Video
    Baking soda, bicarb soda, baking powder. what is the difference?Question: What is the difference between baking powder, baking soda and bicarbonate of soda? What are their different applications? Prince William worried about sleepless nightsPrince William has said he is "very much looking forward" to becoming a father, but admits he is worried about the sleepless nights that await him. Megan Gale on Nicole: Stop bullying our brightest starReacting to the negative media coverage at home of her compatriot Nicole Kidman's appearance on the red carpet here in Cannes, Megan Gale has launched a broadside against the tall poppy syndrome. How to cook a soft-boiled eggThere is a great debate and many points of view on how to boil the perfect egg. However, there are a few points that all the experts agree on. Kindred spirits: Rachel Ward & Bryan BrownThey met and fell in love on the set of The Thorn Birds. Today, more than 25 years later, Rachel Ward and Bryan Brown tell Susan Chenery why they were made for each other and why he is happy to let her call most of the shots.

    What your kids are really up to online

    What your kids are really up to onlineIt's no shock that tweens — children between the ages of eight and 12...More >

    Prince William worried about sleepless...

    Prince William worried about sleepless nightsPrince William has said he is "very much looking forward" to becoming a father,...More >
    The best warming winter soupsThe best warming winter soups Horoscopes by Jessica AdamsHoroscopes by Jessica Adams

    Weekly newsletter

    Recipes in your inboxWe send you the latest recipes from the Weekly plus all the week's best bits to your inbox.
    Sign up now >
    ww |

    topics

    Handy hints(740)/ Expert advice(530)/ Books(451)/ natural health(438)/ Royals(389)/ diet(369)/ Food(358)/ Recipes(349)/ Royal Family(321)/ Health(284)/ Celebrities(253)

    Also on Ninemsn